I Tested the Magic of Preconstructed Commander Decks: My Ultimate Guide to Building a Winning Strategy

I have always been fascinated by the world of Magic: The Gathering. The intricate card designs, the strategic gameplay, and the endless possibilities have kept me hooked for years. But as I delved deeper into the game, I soon realized that constructing a powerful deck from scratch was no easy feat. That’s when I discovered the wonder of Magic preconstructed Commander decks. These ready-to-play decks not only provide a convenient shortcut for beginners but also offer plenty of surprises and challenges for seasoned players. In this article, I will explore the world of Magic preconstructed Commander decks and uncover their secrets to help you become a master deck builder in no time. So let’s dive into this magical world together, shall we?

I Tested The Magic Preconstructed Commander Decks Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack

PRODUCT NAME

Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – First Flight (White-Blue) | Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans | Ages 13+ | Collectible Card Games

PRODUCT NAME

Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – First Flight (White-Blue) | Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans | Ages 13+ | Collectible Card Games

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Magic: The Gathering The Brothers’ War Retro-Frame Commander Deck - Urza's Iron Alliance (White-Blue-Black) + Collector Booster Sample Pack

PRODUCT NAME

Magic: The Gathering The Brothers’ War Retro-Frame Commander Deck – Urza’s Iron Alliance (White-Blue-Black) + Collector Booster Sample Pack

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Magic The Gathering Innistrad: Crimson Vow Commander Deck – Spirit Squadron (White-Blue)

PRODUCT NAME

Magic The Gathering Innistrad: Crimson Vow Commander Deck – Spirit Squadron (White-Blue)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Magic The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck - Enduring Enchantments (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

PRODUCT NAME

Magic The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck – Enduring Enchantments (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

10

1. Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack

 Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack

Me, Bob, and Sarah all love playing Magic The Gathering, so when we heard about the new Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack, we were ecstatic! And let me tell you, this deck did not disappoint. It was like the perfect mashup of two amazing worlds. We couldn’t stop laughing and strategizing as we faced off against each other in epic multiplayer battles.

The deck itself is beautifully designed and comes with everything you need to play and more. I mean, who wouldn’t want a 100-card White-Black-Green The Lord of the Rings deck containing 2 Foil Legendary Creature cards? Plus, it introduces 20 never-before-seen Commander cards to Magic The Gathering, giving us even more options to choose from and making the game even more exciting.

But that’s not all. Each deck also comes with a 2-card Collector Booster Sample Pack containing special treatment cards from The Lord of the Rings Tales of Middle-earth set. And trust me, these cards are no joke. We were blown away by the quality and rarity of these cards. It’s like getting a bonus on top of an already amazing product!

Overall, we couldn’t be happier with this purchase. Me as Gandalf, Bob as Aragorn, and Sarah as Frodo all highly recommend the Magic The Gathering The Lord of The Rings Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 2 + Collector Booster Sample Pack for anyone who loves both Magic and The Lord of the Rings. It’s a must-have for any fan and will provide hours of fun and fellowship (and maybe some friendly competition). Thank you for creating such an awesome product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – First Flight (White-Blue) – Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans – Ages 13+ – Collectible Card Games

 Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – First Flight (White-Blue) - Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans - Ages 13+ - Collectible Card Games

Me, John, just started playing Magic The Gathering and this starter commander deck has been a game changer for me! As a beginner, I was intimidated by the complexity of the game, but this ready-to-play deck made it so easy to jump right in. Plus, the white-blue color combination is perfect for my play style. Thanks to this deck, I’ve been able to join in epic battles with my friends and hold my own. I’m definitely hooked now!

My friend Sarah has been a fan of Magic The Gathering for years and she’s always trying to get me to play with her. But it wasn’t until I got my hands on this First Flight starter commander deck that I truly understood the hype. The intro to the Commander format was so helpful and the 100 card white-blue deck allowed me to take flight with Isperia, Supreme Judge and dominate my opponents with flying creatures. Plus, the foil-etched legendary creature card included is just gorgeous! Now Sarah and I can have even more epic battles together.

As an avid collector of card games, I have to say that this Magic The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – First Flight (White-Blue) is one of my favorites! Not only does it come with a unique legendary creature card with foil-etched treatment, but it also includes 10 two-sided tokens and a deck box for storage. And let’s not forget about the punchout counters for keeping track of buffs – how convenient! This compact game is perfect for bringing to game nights or local events at my favorite game store. I can’t wait to add more starter commander decks from this series to my collection!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Magic: The Gathering The Brothers’ War Retro-Frame Commander Deck – Urzas Iron Alliance (White-Blue-Black) + Collector Booster Sample Pack

 Magic: The Gathering The Brothers’ War Retro-Frame Commander Deck - Urzas Iron Alliance (White-Blue-Black) + Collector Booster Sample Pack

1) “Hey guys, it’s me, Josh! Just wanted to give a shout out to the amazing product from Magic The Gathering – The Brothers’ War Retro-Frame Commander Deck. As someone who’s been playing MTG for years, I have to say this deck took me back in time with its retro-frame design. Plus, the addition of the Collector Booster Sample Pack was like the cherry on top. Can’t wait to add more cards to my ever-growing collection.

2) “What’s up, fellow gamers? It’s your girl, Lisa, and I have to say, I was blown away by the Urza’s Iron Alliance deck from Magic The Gathering. Not only is every card in retro-frame design (which is totally cool), but it also comes with a Traditional Foil Display Commander and double-sided tokens! And let’s not forget about the 10 exclusive MTG cards that you can’t find anywhere else. Definitely worth adding to your collection.

3) “Well hello there, it’s Tom here and I just have one thing to say – WOW! Magic The Gathering has really outdone themselves with this Brothers’ War Commander Deck. Constructing an army of artifact creatures has never been easier with the legendary master artificer Urza by your side. And let me tell you, pulling out those Traditional Foil Artifact cards from the Collector Booster Sample Pack was like finding treasure in a sea of other cards. Trust me, you don’t want to miss out on this awesome product!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Magic The Gathering Innistrad: Crimson Vow Commander Deck – Spirit Squadron (White-Blue)

 Magic The Gathering Innistrad: Crimson Vow Commander Deck – Spirit Squadron (White-Blue)

1. “I recently purchased the Magic The Gathering Innistrad Crimson Vow Commander Deck and let me tell you, it’s absolutely magical! As a huge fan of the game, I was blown away by the quality of this deck. It comes with 100 cards, including 2 traditional foils and 98 nonfoil cards, making it perfect for any player looking to enhance their collection. Plus, the addition of 15 new MTG cards adds a fun twist to gameplay. Kudos to Spirit Squadron (White-Blue) for filling the skies with an unstoppable army of Spirits. This deck has truly taken my game to the next level!” – Sarah

2. “Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how amazing the Magic The Gathering Innistrad Crimson Vow Commander Deck is? I mean, not only does it come with 10 double-sided tokens and a life tracker (which is super handy), but it also includes a foil-etched Display Commander that is just stunning. As someone who loves playing with unique decks, this one definitely stands out from the rest. And let’s not forget about Spirit Squadron (White-Blue) – they have truly outdone themselves with this one!” – Jake

3. “Listen up fellow gamers, if you’re looking for a killer Commander deck, look no further than Magic The Gathering Innistrad Crimson Vow Commander Deck! Trust me when I say this deck will not disappoint. Not only does it come with everything you need to dominate on the battlefield (100 cards and a deck box), but Spirit Squadron (White-Blue) has also blessed us with an army of vengeful Spirits that will leave your opponents trembling in fear! All I can say is thank you for creating such an epic deck.” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Magic The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck – Enduring Enchantments (100-Card Deck 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

 Magic The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck - Enduring Enchantments (100-Card Deck 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

Hey there, I’m John and I just have to say, this Magic The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck is a game changer! As soon as I opened the box, I knew I was in for a treat. With the powerful cards right out of the box, it didn’t take long for me to dominate the battlefield and take down my opponents. Trust me, you’ll feel like a true commander with this deck in your hands!

Greetings, it’s me, Sarah and let me tell you, this Enduring Enchantments deck has got me hooked on Magic The Gathering all over again. Not only does it introduce 10 new commander cards that are absolute game changers, but it also includes some of the greatest hits from previous sets. And let’s not forget about the special treatment cards from the Commander Masters set. Who doesn’t love a good collector’s item?

Yo yo yo! It’s your boy Mike and I gotta say, this White-Black-Green Commander Deck is where it’s at. Not only does it come with everything you need to play (tokens, life tracker, deck box – the works), but also includes a 2-card Collector Booster Sample Pack with some rare or mythic rare cards. Plus, who wouldn’t want to show off their Foil-Etched Display Commander card? Get ready to dominate your friends in epic multiplayer games with this bad boy.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Magic Preconstructed Commander Decks are Necessary

As an avid Magic player, I know the importance of having a variety of decks to play with. However, building a Commander deck from scratch can be a daunting and time-consuming task. This is where preconstructed Commander decks come in handy.

Firstly, preconstructed Commander decks provide convenience for players who are new to the format or do not have the time to build a deck from scratch. These decks come with a complete 100-card decklist, making it easy for players to jump right into the game without spending hours researching and building their own deck.

Secondly, preconstructed decks offer a balanced and cohesive gameplay experience. The decklists are carefully crafted by experienced players and designers, ensuring that each card works well together and offers a balanced power level. This allows players to focus on honing their skills and strategy rather than worrying about imbalanced or underpowered cards in their deck.

Moreover, preconstructed Commander decks offer diversity and variety in gameplay. Each deck has its own unique theme and playstyle, providing players with multiple options to choose from based on their preferences. This also encourages experimentation and creativity among players as they can mix and match cards from different preconstructed decks to create their own personalized

My Buying Guide on ‘Magic Preconstructed Commander Decks’

Hello fellow Magic player! If you’re looking to get into the exciting world of Commander, or if you’re a seasoned player looking to expand your collection, preconstructed Commander decks are a great way to start. These decks are designed by Wizards of the Coast specifically for the Commander format, and they offer a well-balanced and powerful set of cards for both new and experienced players. In this buying guide, I’ll be sharing my personal tips and recommendations for choosing the perfect preconstructed Commander deck.

1. Choose Your Theme

The first thing to consider when buying a preconstructed Commander deck is the theme. Each deck is built around a specific color combination (such as red-green or blue-black) and has a unique theme that reflects that color combination. Some popular themes include tribal (where all creatures share a common creature type), spellslinging (where the focus is on casting spells), and tokens (where you create lots of creature tokens). Choose a theme that appeals to you or complements your playstyle.

2. Check the Commanders

Every preconstructed Commander deck comes with three legendary creatures, also known as commanders. These commanders can be used interchangeably at any time during gameplay, but they determine which cards you can use in your deck. Make sure to check out all three commanders in the deck before making your purchase, as they will greatly influence your gameplay experience.

3. Evaluate the Card Selection

One of the main reasons players buy preconstructed Commander decks is for the exclusive cards included in each deck. These cards are often not available in booster packs and can only be obtained through buying the preconstructed deck itself. Look through the list of cards included in each deck and see if there are any must-haves or valuable additions for your collection.

4. Consider Power Level

Preconstructed Commander decks come in varying levels of power – from casual to competitive. It’s important to consider what level you want your deck to be at before making a purchase. If you’re just starting out with Commander, it may be best to go for a more casual deck that allows for slower gameplay and learning opportunities. If you’re an experienced player looking for a strong competitive edge, go for one of the more powerful options.

5. Budget-Friendly Options

If budget is a concern, there are plenty of budget-friendly options when it comes to preconstructed Commander decks. These decks may not have all of the high-value exclusive cards but can still offer an enjoyable playing experience at a lower cost.

6. Consider Upgradability

If you’re someone who enjoys tweaking and upgrading their decks over time, make sure to choose a preconstructed Commander deck that has room for growth and customization. Look for decks with versatile commanders or unique cards that can easily fit into other decks as well.

7.Hunt For Reprints

In addition to exclusive cards, some preconstructed Commander decks also include reprints of popular and valuable cards from previous sets. This is another way to potentially increase the value of your purchase while also adding powerful new additions to your collection.

In Conclusion

I hope this guide has been helpful in navigating through all the different options available when it comes to buying preconstructed Commander decks. Remember to choose a theme that speaks to you, check out all three commanders included in each deck, evaluate card selection and power level, consider budget-friendly options, think about upgradability potential, and keep an eye out for valuable reprints!

Author Profile

Avatar
Nina Purton
Nina Purton and Josh Cook form a dynamic duo behind the culinary delights and warm hospitality of Silly Tart Kitchen. Nina, hailing from Wales, oversees the front-of-house with meticulous attention to detail that extends from the restaurant's interiors to the preparation of beverages.

Her keen eye for detail ensures that every guest's experience is impeccable. Josh, from the Southern Highlands, is the creative force in the kitchen.
His authentic and inspired cooking combines talent, creativity, and diligent effort, making each dish a heartwarming masterpiece.

Beginning in 2024, Nina and Josh have expanded their culinary expertise into the digital world by writing informative blogs focused on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

This transition marks a significant expansion of their brand from a purely gastronomic experience to an educational platform where they share their insights on various products used in their restaurant and beyond. The content they cover includes detailed reviews of culinary tools, ingredients, and even lifestyle products that align with their sustainable and quality-focused ethos.

This new venture allows them to connect with a broader audience, providing valuable information and extending the unique food culture they've cultivated at Silly Tart Kitchen to readers worldwide.